The Best Trump Comedy Hour That (almost) No One Saw
Last night I had a live recording of Making Podcasts Great Again in Rutherford, New Jersey. Making Podcasts Great Again is the show I have done for 6 1/2 years every week without missing a week as Donald Trump. In 2020 we saw exponential growth commensurate with the exponential exposure I got for my viral videos of Trump and other political figures. Over the last couple of years I reluctantly continued the show as Trump maintained his stranglehold on American politics and culture, but I decided 2024 would be the last year of the show. As part of the farewell me and my show co-host, Jay Nog, scheduled a few live shows around the country. This is the recap of the New Jersey show.
I arrived at the venue in my suit at 725 (my Lyft driver took a wrong turn or I would have been there earlier) for the 745 show. Fortunately Jay had gotten everything set up and our opener and friend, Chris Lamberth, was there. He would be doing double duty as both our warm up act and our special interview guest mid show. I had messaged a NJ celebrity who follows me to be our guest but got no reply. A prominent NJ politician spoke with me on the phone but politely declined to be our guest. So Chris stepped up to fill the gap (and for his efforts and the lack of attendance would leave the show as its highest paid participant).
Halfway through Chris’ twenty minute warm up set I threw on my red tie and blonde wig and began meandering around the theater lobby. An older woman working there had the following conversation with me:
Woman: You’re playing Trump?
Me: Yep.
Woman: Are you voting for him?
Me: Nope!
Woman: oh, you’re not voting?
Me: Oh I’m voting. Just not for him.
Woman: Have you read his books?
Me: Nope!
Woman: His books show you the real him. You can’t trust the media… (trails off)
Then it was time for me to enter the theater to YMCA.
Now I had conservatively hoped that for my show which had once clocked 20K listens and downloads a week, plus my status as a New Jersey Q-list celebrity since 2020, would get us a minimum of 50 sales, but was really hoping for at least 100, especially given that we are a month from a consequential election. I clearly was not conservative enough, because I think we had 25 audience members (with an additional 5 seats bought by a big fan for us to donate to listeners of the podcast – zero listeners requested any of the 5 free tickets). I quickly shook of my disappointment and what transpired over the next hour was the best episode in the show’s history and the best personal performance of my career in any way, with the exception of the first taping (album version) of Half-Blackface. It was that good and I was that good.
Despite the show, I have been in a funk most of today because I have reached the undeniable conclusion that my time has come and gone. When I asked the audience last night how many people there listened to the podcast, exactly zero said yes. So a Trump impression that has garnered about 40 million views has led to a microscopic percentage becoming listeners of a free Trump podcast. And of that percentage, none appeared to attend the show last night (though, from a just received email it seems one listener did attend). I have friends, family and a lot of fans in New Jersey, but whether it is bad luck, a loss of heat (though not of talent or new content), a changing culture of entertainment or some other reason, the career I have built and the audience I have attracted are not conducive to selling tickets (St Paul, MN appeared to be an outlier earlier this month).
But last night felt different. The tragic irony of last night was that I really did have one of the greatest shows of my life in front of that small, but appreciative audience. The episode should be up later this week when we get the audio, but the “Black Panther endorsed me” rant which was either 2 minutes or 20 minutes long (I really lost myself in it) might be the funniest thing I have ever done. The greatest reward was probably seeing both Jay and Chris busting up laughing during the improv. But the frustration that has set in today is something beyond the usual “post show crash” that can happen. My biggest fear for many years has been making good work that does not get seen or heard. This has nothing to do with fame or money. But when I did not make some Internet “Top 10 Trump impressions” earlier this year it dawned on me that both the consumption and recognition I admittedly crave are not coming. And the irony is that the better the shows I have, the more disappointed I am. And last night was an absolute masterpiece.
The show was going so well I did the thing I am often incapable of doing: held my tongue in the face of blatant disrespect. One audience member, who was with a very supportive fan (which I learned after the fact) was doing fairly loud commentary throughout the show. It was often repeating punchlines or simply proclaiming his enjoyment loudly, and that would have only registered as annoying. But at one point a phone went off. I made a passing comment (always in character), but then it went off again. I then said something again, to which this audience member said, “there’s like 15 people in here.” Now having a great show is always a challenge. But having a killer show while fighting off the deep disappointment of subpar ticket sales is an even greater victory. Apparently this person felt that a small audience was not worthy of respectful behavior. Conversely, I think that the fans who did show up deserve even more respect because their individual presence is that much more essential and appreciated. So I let it slide again to not ruin the show. And mind you, when not offering snide comments or echo responses he was laughing hysterically. However, the worst was yet to come.
At the end of our live shows we do a Q&A (not for tik tok content BS, but because people want to interact with the impression(s)). The rude audience member asked a question, but then towards the end (two questions left) I heard him say “OK, this is done.” Now everyone was laughing still, but it took everything I had not to hurl the microphone at this person and choose violence. In fact, I stayed in the green room after the show because I would rather miss fans and avoid being enraged than thank my fans and risk losing my temper.
So if any of my fans who were there read this or end up listening to the podcast, thank you for being there. I have the type of career where I have hundreds of thousands of followers (the most passive level of fan), but far fewer real fans. I did not have a real choice in who followed me and I am grateful for all the exposure, but I have a deep appreciation for the real fans I do have. I just wish their support could be rewarded with a more successful comedian.
Last night’s show was like that old “if a tree falls in the forest , but no one is around, does it make a sound?” saying. What I can say is that last night a couple dozen people saw that best Trump parody that has ever been. I am certain of that. So it may not make a blip on Hollywood’s radar, but it certainly made a lot of sound last night.
1 COMMENT
This wasn’t easy reading, J-L
Best wishes and respect